We decided to give the dads/ menfolk in the family (my dad, DH, BIL, my ex -DD19's dad and my 14 yr old nephew) a joint experience gift. They'll be going to the sporting club where DD19 works for an afternoon of archery, something they've all wanted to do but never tried. DD gets a staff discount too.
There is a huge saving by booking them as a group, probably half of what it would have cost to give them as individual gifts. That saving doesn't include any staff discount. The gift will end up costing about $12 - 15 per person
It's getting more and more difficult to find budget friendly Father's day gifts that they will actually enjoy.