what about nice candles or soap sets? I try to get things like that for teachers or hostess gifts. that way if they don't what them they can regift them. Partylite mini barrel candles are very nice with lots of scents and last a long time. that is what the teachers are getting this year.
I have to think about what to get because I get repeat teachers so can't give them the same thing as before.
Or something I got from dh school xmas fair was cookie mix in a mason jar that was decorated fancy with ribbon and fake leaves etc. the decorations really made the jars special. the gingerbread one had a cookie cutter attached. I think it was 3 for $15 or 20 dollars. worth it. that was the teachers xmas gift.
dd teacher really liked it and the fact it would look nice displayed in the kitchen.
the nice thing about soap, candles etc instead of food is they don't go bad so you can keep them for other times.