Not sure how silly these are, but here's my list:
iPod already loaded w/50 or so songs (I'm not good w/computer tech stuff). You did say forget being frugal! Last week I saw one for $45 that holds 200 songs, but I don't know enough about them to know if it was a good one.
A big box of crayons & a cool coloring book (butterflies, flowers or something that would use lots of color). I've never had one of those giant boxes w/the sharpner!
A cool pair of knitted gloves or mittens (electric blue or something), a neat key ring, a super bouncey ball, a matchbox car like my 1st car (how cool would that be)!
Homemade coupons for activities like an afternoon antiquing with a friend, a baking/cooking lesson & a craft lesson with a friend or family member. I remember see the lessons idea for kids, but I'd love it. Even better if I could choose the recipe or craft to be made!
I could list a bunch more (most aren't silly like Burt's Bees stuff, cool lip gloss, lottery tickets). I just see so many cool suggestions that I'd love, it's easy to get carried away! Almost forgot my candy... smarties, blow pops or old fashion stick candy.