Glue Sticks - They're acid free, so great for use in scrapbooking, cardmaking.
Notebooks/composition books - I use these for my daily to-do lists.
Crayons/markers - great to have on hand if you have small kids. Save some for stocking stuffers, Easter baskets, birthday party favors, etc.
Markers and crayons for coloring and craft projects.
Spiral notebooks: I write down recipes I want to try in them. I get the magazines from the library or from friends, and then I just write down the ones I want to try. I also have notebooks dedicated to kid's craft ideas I come across and frugal tips.
Crayons are 20 cents at Walmart this time of year so we buy 50 boxes and get dollar store curling ribbons and tie on them for party favors for both kids. We also get the washable markers when they are 88cents and buy like 10 some for home, some for stocking stuffers. Sometimes if I have enough cash on hand I buy extra crayons, markers, construction paper, glue sticks, scissors etc., playdoh and put together in cutre dollar store bags to use as gifts when my kids go to birthday parties. It turns out to be about a $7-$10 gift and every parent we've ever given one to their kid at a party is thrilled and thankful that its not useless junk. We also do this for secret Sister gift exchange too.
I also bought extra crayons this year because I plan on putting a box of crayons in each of your Christmas gifts story sacks.
I picked up some colored pencils I am going to put them in my dd's art tote that I'm making her for Christmas.